Talk:Danube validation

Dear Ms Krämer, that's a good start! Best regards Wendelin Schramm 11:14, 13 November 2007 (CET)

... and it is geting even better ;-) Wendelin Schramm 18:29, 22 November 2007 (CET)

Thank you, I hope I'm doing this the way you expect it to be. Nkraemer 12:40, 24 November 2007 (CET)

What has been corrected in the validation process before 8. January 2008: --Wendelin Schramm 22:36, 14 January 2008 (CET)

• • Sheet: i_Parameters
    1. Discounting : has been checked and all mistakes have been eliminated
    2. QALY: has been checked and all mistakes have been eliminated
    3. Initial Population: has been checked and the following mistakes still have to be eliminated
       • (F31) 'total' doesn't calculate the sum.
    4. Cohort definitions:
       • (F36) 'sex male' doesn't calculate the difference to 'sex female' (F35)
       • (F39) 'nonsmoker' doesn't calculate the difference to 'smoker' (F38)
       • (F43) 'blood pressure MAP': MAP not calculated
    5. Therapy effects: has been checked and all mistakes have been eliminated
  • Sheet: c_Summary
    1. No Nephropathy: has been checked and all mistakes have been eliminated
    2. Microalbuminuria: has been checked and all mistakes have been eliminated
    3. Macroalbuminuria: has been checked and all mistakes have been eliminated
    4. Acute renal disease: has been checked and all mistakes have been eliminated
  • Sheet: c_GP
    1. GP consultation (No Nephropathy, Microalbuminuria, Macroalbuminuria, Acute renal disease) : has been checked and all mistakes have been eliminated
    2. Specialist consultation (No Nephropathy, Microalbuminuria, Macroalbuminuria, Acute renal disease) : has been checked and all mistakes have been eliminated
  • Sheet: c_Hospital
    1. No Nephropathy, Microalbuminuria, Macroalbuminuria, Acute renal disease: has been checked and all mistakes have been eliminated
    2. Average German Base- rate: has been checked and all mistakes have been eliminated
    3. Out-of-pocket: 'total' doesn't necessarily have to take the sum of the upper 9 cells
  • Sheet: c_Drugs
    1. No Nephropathy, Microalbuminuria, Macroalbuminuria, Acute renal disease:has been checked and all mistakes have been eliminated. Maybe the user should be informed about the possible changes he can make (otherwise he changes i.e. the Price/unit, which changes the calculation)
    2. Out-of-pocket: has been checked and all mistakes have been eliminated
  • Sheet: c_Monitoring
    1. No Nephropathy, Microalbuminuria, Macroalbuminuria, Acute renal disease: has been checked and all mistakes have been eliminated
  • Sheet: c_Dialysis
    1. Haemodialysis: has been checked and all mistakes have been eliminated
    2. Peritoneal Dialysis: has been checked and all mistakes have been eliminated
  • Sheet: c_Out-of-pocket
    1. No Nephropathy, Microalbuminuria, Macroalbuminuria, Acute renal disease: has been checked and all mistakes have been eliminated
  • Sheet: p_summary
    1. Error- warnings in F16- F551 are not shown correctly
    2. Transition Probabilities in summary are equal with transition probabilities in following sheets.
  • Sheet: p_1
    1. Formular for p1: p16 hast to be changed to p13
    2. Cells p13, p2 and p1: have been checked and all mistakes have been eliminated
  • Sheet: p_2
    1. f_{ace_inhibitor} still has to be checked (compare to sheet p_5)
  • Sheet: p_3
    1. Formular for f1 unclear
    2. f_{ace_inhibitor} still has to be checked (compare to sheet p_5)
  • Sheet: p_4
    1. All cells have been checked and all mistakes have been eliminated
  • Sheet: p_5
    1. f_{ace_inhibitor} still has to be checked (compare to sheet p_3)
  • Sheet: p_6
    1. All cells have been checked and all mistakes have been eliminated
  • Sheet: p_7
    1. All cells have been checked and all mistakes have been eliminated
  • Sheet: p_8
    1. All cells have been checked and all mistakes have been eliminated
  • Sheet: p_9
    1. All cells have been checked and all mistakes have been eliminated
  • Sheet: p_10
    1. All cells have been checked and all mistakes have been eliminated
  • Sheet: p_11
    1. Description of the transition probability still includes "p14" instead of "p11"
    2. All cells have been checked and all mistakes have been eliminated
  • Sheet: p_12
    1. Description of the transition probability still includes "p15" instead of "p12"
    2. All cells have been checked and all mistakes have been eliminated
  • Sheet: p_13
    1. Description of the transition probability still includes "p16" instead of "p13"
    2. All cells have been checked and all mistakes have been eliminated
  • Markov Model
    1. (K59) not assignable fomular
    2. (P36) not assignable calculation
    3. no inflation rate included in Costs
    4. (F147 + G147) unlabled calculations
  • Diagramm
    1. Caption of the Diagramm should be improved ("progression to MAU", instead of "Spalte I")
  • Cummulated Incidences
    1. x-Axis and y-Axis should be labled
  • Deaths by States
    1. x-Axis and y-Axis should be labled
  • o_LE
    1. Total has to be summarized to line 78 instead of line 43
    2. H81 is no calculation!
  • o_Costs
    1. The Costs (J16-N76) and discounted costs should ALL rely on the Markov model cost-calculation
    2. Halfcycle- correction for the discounted costs (K15) is included twice.
    3. (F79) Why is the total amount divided by 25?
  • o_Cos_utility
    1. All cells have been checked and all mistakes have been eliminated
  • Documentaion
    1. Not all names are mentioned
  • AutoTesting
    1. All cells have been checked and all mistakes have been eliminated